New Yorker Bagels

Karen Breeding 4 months ago

I can't express my disappointment in this product enough. They in no way resemble any bagel you would find in New York or any decent bagel you could find in any other state in the union. I purchased 2 dozen bagels for my native New Yorker husband for his birthday and he was very excited to receive. They arrived on time, well packaged. The product itself is hugely disappointing, and in no way resembles a bagel I've seen outside the supermarket. In fact, most supermarket bakery bagels are far, far superior to this. The texture resembles packaged sliced bread (there is absolutely no "chew," just a mealy consistency) and the uniformity of appearance suggest these are mass produced by machinery. The different flavors are just toppings sprinkled on top plain (or egg) bagels. I checked their website again this morning, and the photos (never mind the testimonials!) are ingenuous. My bagels don't resemble what is pictured here at all. I paid $49 for two dozen bagels when I could have found better bagels at the local Safeway.

The Hunter 7 months ago

So I recently sent bagels from another bagel maker through the big food delivery service to relatives at Christmas. They were excellent so I ordered some. I was telling another cousin about my recent find and she suggested these. She does a lot of charcuterie and uses the mini bagels alot. So I ordered these. This company is way more organized with ordering and instructions. The bagels were about an ounce smaller but they were delicious. I would definitely order from here again. Packaging and literature are top notch

Bill Me 9 months ago

Ok, these folks go above and beyond. We had a box of bagels sent to us as a holiday gift but we were on the road. They said if they redirected the shipment the bagels would not be at their best when they arrived so they shipped us a second box to outlet vacation spot at no charge! Thank you NY bagels, we know what we are having for breakfast 😀

Davis Davis Edited 7 months ago

Ordered from North Carolina and got updates every step of the way—delivery arrived in just two days, exactly as promised. I ordered the Everything and Onion bagels, and they’re everything I wanted! Perfectly chewy inside, with a tough outer crust that can only come from NYC! They freeze and thaw easily, and after a quick bake in the oven (as instructed), they taste like they just came out of a bakery. Thank you, New Yorker Bagels! I was skeptical about ordering, but I’m completely satisfied and will definitely order again. Update- Still delicious if not better 3 months later! Followed directions provided-Stored in freezer, remove at least 30min prior and bake 4-5mins at 400.

Robin Caltagirone 2 years ago

A dear friend ordered these bagels shipped to Charlotte NC. We absolutely LOVED the bagels!! Fiancé said they were the best bagels he’s had! Shipped in New Yorker Bagels 🥯 😍 Toasted an everything bagel first, followed by the French toast bagel. Tasted before and after toasting and before and after Violife Vegan Cream Cheese (our personal favorite, yes even over Philadelphia). EXCELLENT!! While Bagel-Gram is good, NOTHING beats these shipped in!!